Prophetess Anna in Art: 10 Historical Temple Paintings

Ambrogio Lorenzetti’s Presentation at the Temple, with the prophetess Anna holding a scroll

An elderly woman holding a scroll in Ambrogio Lorenzetti’s Presentation is a good place to begin looking for Anna. Her role is easier to read there than in many scenes centred on Simeon. These ten paintings compare works in which she is identifiable with broader Temple scenes that give the witnesses less space. That difference is part of the history of how the episode was painted.

Explore the contemporary prints →

In this guide

  1. Presentation at the Temple · Ambrogio Lorenzetti
  2. Simeon’s Song of Praise · Rembrandt, 1631
  3. Simeon in the Temple · Rembrandt, c. 1669
  4. The Presentation at the Temple · Gentile da Fabriano
  5. The Presentation in the Temple · Fra Angelico
  6. Presentation in the Temple · Hans Holbein the Elder
  7. The Presentation in the Temple · Raphael
  8. The Presentation in the Temple · Simon Vouet
  9. Presentation in the Temple · Gerbrand van den Eeckhout
  10. Presentation in the Temple · Giandomenico Tiepolo

Who is Anna in Luke’s Gospel?

Luke 2:36–38 identifies Anna as a prophetess, the daughter of Phanuel, from the tribe of Asher. He describes her as an elderly widow who worshipped with fasting and prayer. She thanks God and speaks about Jesus to people awaiting the redemption of Jerusalem. Simeon holds the child and gives the canticle earlier in the chapter. Anna’s work in the story is public testimony.

1. Presentation at the Temple · Ambrogio Lorenzetti

Presentation at the Temple · Ambrogio Lorenzetti
Presentation at the Temple · Ambrogio Lorenzetti

Look for the scroll. The Uffizi identifies the elderly prophetess by this attribute. The Temple is imagined as a medieval church, with the floor and columns drawing the eye toward the rite. Anna’s scroll keeps the act of testimony visible within all that architecture.

View the reproduction →

Museum or catalogue note

2. Simeon’s Song of Praise · Rembrandt, 1631

Simeon’s Song of Praise · Rembrandt, 1631
Simeon’s Song of Praise · Rembrandt, 1631

The temple interior dwarfs the people below. The Frick identifies Anna among the figures close to the child, where her blessing becomes part of a larger scene of recognition. In this version, viewers have to find the witnesses within a wide field of shadow.

View the reproduction →

Museum or catalogue note

3. Simeon in the Temple · Rembrandt, c. 1669

Simeon in the Temple · Rembrandt, c. 1669
Simeon in the Temple · Rembrandt, c. 1669

The later picture concentrates almost everything on Simeon and the child. Notice the woman behind them, whose identity should be approached with care in this unfinished painting. Compare how far a viewer has to look for the surrounding witnesses in the 1631 composition.

View the reproduction →

Museum or catalogue note

4. The Presentation at the Temple · Gentile da Fabriano

The Presentation at the Temple · Gentile da Fabriano
The Presentation at the Temple · Gentile da Fabriano

The predella panel embeds the event in a busy architectural setting. Look among the columns for the older witness near the central group. Comparing this chamber with Lorenzetti’s temple makes it easier to see how painters use architecture to place witnesses within the event.

View the reproduction →

Museum or catalogue note

5. The Presentation in the Temple · Fra Angelico

The Presentation in the Temple · Fra Angelico
The Presentation in the Temple · Fra Angelico

The spare grouping and rhythmic architecture lead the eye toward the exchange at the altar. Compare the room left for witnesses with Rembrandt’s expansive interior. A simple backdrop can make the placement and gestures of each person easier to read.

View the reproduction →

6. Presentation in the Temple · Hans Holbein the Elder

Presentation in the Temple · Hans Holbein the Elder
Presentation in the Temple · Hans Holbein the Elder

The Kaisheim panel gathers the figures into a compact ceremonial space. Read the scene from the central action outward and ask which witnesses the painter allows to share the viewer’s attention. The distribution of faces is as revealing as the prominence of the child.

View the reproduction →

7. The Presentation in the Temple · Raphael

The Presentation in the Temple · Raphael
The Presentation in the Temple · Raphael

In the Oddi predella, open architecture and a wide horizontal format let the encounter unfold as a group scene. Follow the rhythm of the figures to see how the painter leads from the margins back to the exchange.

View the reproduction →

Museum or catalogue note

8. The Presentation in the Temple · Simon Vouet

The Presentation in the Temple · Simon Vouet
The Presentation in the Temple · Simon Vouet

The great masses of architecture and the turning figures spread the action across a larger stage. Look to the edges of the central exchange for the witnesses. The Louvre’s account helps place this scale in the original setting of the painting.

View the reproduction →

Museum or catalogue note

9. Presentation in the Temple · Gerbrand van den Eeckhout

Presentation in the Temple · Gerbrand van den Eeckhout
Presentation in the Temple · Gerbrand van den Eeckhout

The scene offers another comparison from the Dutch tradition. Read the illuminated figures first, then take time to identify the less prominent onlookers. Lighting can give the transfer of the child a clear centre while leaving the congregation as a setting for witness.

View the reproduction →

10. Presentation in the Temple · Giandomenico Tiepolo

Presentation in the Temple · Giandomenico Tiepolo
Presentation in the Temple · Giandomenico Tiepolo

The stepped arrangement offers a later counterpart to the compact panels. The viewer follows the grouping of people along the ceremony. Compare that sense of movement with Lorenzetti, where the scroll gives one witness a more explicit place.

View the reproduction →

Look for Anna beyond the centre

A scroll or a raised hand can help identify Anna, but an older woman in a Temple scene should not be named on appearance alone. Compare two more treatments: the Hamburger Kunsthalle’s Simeon and Hannah in the Temple and the Rijksmuseum’s Old Woman Reading, Probably the Prophetess Anna. The latter’s title preserves the uncertainty around the subject.

Read more about the Presentation in the Temple.

See the contemporary Anna prints →