Angelic Choirs in 10 Historical Christmas Paintings

Botticelli’s Mystic Nativity showing a ring of dancing angels above the stable

Some painters render the heavenly host as a ring, others as musicians, and others as a small group of hardly moving witnesses. These ten historical Christmas paintings show the range of those choices, from the gold sky of Botticelli’s Mystic Nativity to the dark stillness of Geertgen’s Nativity at Night.

Explore the contemporary prints →

In this guide

  1. Mystic Nativity · Sandro Botticelli
  2. Concert of Angels and Nativity · Matthias Grünewald
  3. The Nativity · Piero della Francesca
  4. The Nativity at Night · Geertgen tot Sint Jans
  5. The Nativity with the Prophets Isaiah and Ezekiel · Duccio di Buoninsegna
  6. The Nativity · Petrus Christus
  7. The Nativity with Two Angels · Filippino Lippi
  8. The Nativity · Robert Campin
  9. The Holy Night · Correggio
  10. Nativity and Adoration of the Shepherds · Bartolo di Fredi

The multitude in Luke’s Christmas story

In Luke 2:8–14, the shepherds first hear one angel give them a sign. The multitude then appears and praises God. Luke gives no instruments or detailed description of the host. The circle, the winged musicians and the ranks of singers are ways artists have made that short episode visible. In a painting, the host may also appear over the stable, compressing several moments of the story into one image.

1. Mystic Nativity · Sandro Botticelli

Mystic Nativity · Sandro Botticelli
Mystic Nativity · Sandro Botticelli

Look for the ring of twelve angels high above the stable and the smaller group on the roof. The circle gives praise the form of a dance. The painting also introduces an apocalyptic dimension, as the National Gallery explains, so its imagery reaches beyond a literal reading of the night in Luke.

View the reproduction →

Museum or collection note

2. Concert of Angels and Nativity · Matthias Grünewald

Concert of Angels and Nativity · Matthias Grünewald
Concert of Angels and Nativity · Matthias Grünewald

This part of the Isenheim Altarpiece gives the angel musicians an architectural space next to the Nativity. Your eye moves from the concentrated brilliance of the concert to the mother and child. The joined panels make the music feel close without placing the instruments in the stable.

View the reproduction →

Museum or collection note

3. The Nativity · Piero della Francesca

The Nativity · Piero della Francesca
The Nativity · Piero della Francesca

The musicians stand together near the child, one of the clearest examples here of the choir as an earthly-looking ensemble. The measured poses and the clear separation of the figures let viewers imagine a song even in the stillness of the panel.

View the reproduction →

Museum or collection note

4. The Nativity at Night · Geertgen tot Sint Jans

The Nativity at Night · Geertgen tot Sint Jans
The Nativity at Night · Geertgen tot Sint Jans

The small angels around the child draw near while the shepherds’ encounter occurs further away. Light separates these zones. The painting rewards a close look because the distant announcement and the adoration in the foreground register at very different scales.

View the reproduction →

Museum or collection note

5. The Nativity with the Prophets Isaiah and Ezekiel · Duccio di Buoninsegna

The Nativity with the Prophets Isaiah and Ezekiel · Duccio di Buoninsegna
The Nativity with the Prophets Isaiah and Ezekiel · Duccio di Buoninsegna

The angels cluster around the rocky setting while the prophets flank the central image. The arrangement sets prophecy, birth and announcement into one devotional structure. Look for the smaller encounter with the shepherds, where the messenger carries a scroll.

View the reproduction →

Museum or collection note

6. The Nativity · Petrus Christus

The Nativity · Petrus Christus
The Nativity · Petrus Christus

Four angels kneel near the infant beneath a prominent stone arch. There is little outward movement compared with Botticelli. The bent bodies and the arch bring attention down toward the ground, making the angels witnesses within the scene.

View the reproduction →

Museum or collection note

7. The Nativity with Two Angels · Filippino Lippi

The Nativity with Two Angels · Filippino Lippi
The Nativity with Two Angels · Filippino Lippi

Mary’s kneeling figure is the compositional anchor. Two attendants are enough to place emphasis on the relation between heaven and the child. Think of this as a quiet counterpart to the public and collective outburst of praise in Luke.

View the reproduction →

Museum or collection note

8. The Nativity · Robert Campin

The Nativity · Robert Campin
The Nativity · Robert Campin

Follow the banderoles through the upper part of the picture. In early Netherlandish painting these painted strips can make speech or song visible. They also give the eye a different path from the low cluster of people nearest the infant.

View the reproduction →

9. The Holy Night · Correggio

The Holy Night · Correggio
The Holy Night · Correggio

The child illuminates the people gathered around him, while the angels form a separate, energetic group above. The two sources of pictorial interest let a viewer read the stable as intimate and the upper register as expansive.

View the reproduction →

Museum or collection note

10. Nativity and Adoration of the Shepherds · Bartolo di Fredi

Nativity and Adoration of the Shepherds · Bartolo di Fredi
Nativity and Adoration of the Shepherds · Bartolo di Fredi

A compact sequence puts the angels and the shepherds into the same field as the birth. The semicircle aloft is a good detail to compare with Botticelli’s complete ring. One arrangement points toward the events below; the other makes a larger movement around an opening in heaven.

View the reproduction →

Museum or collection note

Three ways to make praise visible

Compare Botticelli’s ring, Piero’s ensemble and Geertgen’s quiet figures. Repetition makes the first feel like dance, instruments suggest sound in the second, and proximity to the child establishes a different kind of attention in the third. The angels do not need to look alike to connect heaven and earth.

Read about the angel’s first announcement to the shepherds.

See the contemporary Christmas prints →